19 Aug 2009

There is no Joomla community

Written by Brian Teeman
joomla community

Many years ago, when I was young and innocent, I lived in a self-sufficient "closed" community but now that I am older, and more mature (?), it is more accurate to say that today I chose to "participate" or "belong" to several different communities.

In the world of Free/Libre and Open Source Software (F/LOSS) the word "community" is used as a badge, often without any true understanding  of what the word really means.

Joomla, like many F/LOSS projects, claims to be a community project but have you thought what that really means?

"A community is nothing more than a group of individuals congregating together for whatever particular purpose they choose to be in such a group"

  1. What does that mean in the world of joomla?
  2. Is there a shared purpose?
  3. Is there really such a thing as a joomla community?

Mitch Pirtle, a fellow co-founder of Joomla & OpenSource Matters, said to me several years ago that there was "... no such thing as the joomla community ..." and he is right. [Doesn't often happen that Mitch and I agree]

The fabled "joomla community" does not exist, Joomla is a "community of communities"!

  1. A community of users
  2. A community of consumers
  3. A community of friends

Together these communities, and there are obviously multiple groupings and combinations of each type, form the "Joomla community of communities". Labelling a group as a "community" certainly does not imply or require that group to be an elected democracy, nor does it imply that "everyone's opinion counts equally" within the group. But they are still a community.

Is Joomla a community project?

It is but perhaps not in the same generalised terms as some people think.

Joomla is:

  1. community designed
  2. community developed
  3. community driven
  4. community supported

That does not mean that every individual in the "Joomla community of communities" participates in, or is entitled to a say in any of those areas but they can if they want to.

So yes Joomla is a community project and there are Joomla communities but it is up to you as an individual to make the effort to become part of that community.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

About Brian Teeman

  • As a co-founder of Joomla! and OpenSourceMatters Inc I've never been known to be lacking an opinion or being too afraid to express it.

    Despite what some people might think I'm a shy and modest man who doesnt like to blow his own trumpet or boast about achievements.

    But it seems that no blog exists without an "About" page so rather than talk about what an amazingly great guy I am and list all the things I've achieved (and failed at) in life from my Cycling Proficiency Test in 1976 to winning an award for the "UK Individual Contribution to Open / Source" in 2005 here are some links.

    {...}